poetry book club: a review of deborah keenan’s willow room, green door

I come from a long line of writers; I’ve only met a few of them.

After three years of graduate school, this is one of the most significant things I learned. Writers come from a long line of other writers, and the line stretches back as far as their reading habits. I learned this lesson from Deborah Keenan, my professor and principal thesis advisor, and author of Willow Room, Green Door: New and Selected Poems.

Reading Keenan’s newest poems in this collection, I was struck by how intentionally and specifically she lists her influences, as an act of homage and a point of reference. Her influences range from the literary to the artistic and even the musical. She carries on a conversation with other artists, rooted from her reflections on their work. She adapts their words and images, grapples with their meanings and twists them into something new. She quotes Jackson and Rukeyeser, names Kandinsky and Hockney, invites them inside.

Taken as an entire collection, Willow Room, Green Door is a record to living a creative life. Not living it as a Zen Buddhist or a Bohemian dropout, but as a teacher, mother, writer and wife. While reading the book, it is clear that she is conflicted about this type of existence. For instance, in “It’s a Book about Summer, So Cottonwoods and the River are Key” she writes:

… Every poet she knows
Who actually believes in the idea of making meaning
Lists the names of trees. Now that she is so much older
She understands all that she does as an artist that allows
Other artists to render her invisible. She
Is interested in how power works in her world. Why Cezanne
Wins every art brawl. Why his edges aren’t edges, why
The poet who says jacaranda wins and the poet who says
lilac loses … (21)

She acknowledges the dark side of living a creative life, of dedicating yourself to writing despite public accolades or “winning.” Particularly in this poem, she places this choice of creativity within a larger context of the seasons and the Iraq War, two alternate ways of marking the passage of time and the assignation of value. Art is valuable, but some art is more valuable. Life is valuable, but some lives are more valuable. She speaks up for the less valued in the world.

In another new poem, she writes of the need for “the beginning of a new art movement that would honor all that is small and precise.” (29) Her attention to the small and precise is evident throughout the book. In “Loving Motels,” from her 1995 collection Happiness, she accumulates all of the details of a motel stay - the phones and bathing suits and room service - and creates a collage of America. (176) In the mirrored poems “The Man Who Knew About Winter,” and “The Woman Who Knew About Winter”, from an earlier collection Household Wounds, she paints a portrait of a marriage in the details: a wife singing while making dinner, children mishearing song lyrics.

Before I started to read this book, I had hoped to uncover the trajectory of my teacher’s career, to find the line she has forged throughout her lifetime. Instead, I found a more cyclical arc. Willow Room, Green Door is arranged anti-chronologically. Her newest poems are followed by her oldest. This way, the consistency of Keenan’s vision and voice are highlighted. Certain themes recur throughout her work: wars (both new and old), living with family, the struggle to be good and faithful to yourself and your loved ones, and of course, a vital relationship with art. I think if writers strive for a daily practice, they should search out Deborah Keenan’s work, to see what a life lived through a creative lens looks like.

* * *

Keenan, Deborah. (2007). Willow Room, Green Door: New and Selected Poems. Minneapolis: Milkweed Editions .

1. MamaShift - April 3, 2008

I wish you could link to an independent bookseller.

2. Jessica - April 3, 2008

I think that’s a good point.

When I started PBC, I did my due dilligance and looked at all the independent bookstores in my city (Minneapolis, a mid-sized metro) and I always had difficulty finding the book. Then, I would go the big box bookstores and couldn’t find the book either. I finally would default to Amazon and find it there.

After a while, I honestly stopped trying to find poetry in brick-and-mortar stores. I buy other books from my local indies, or rent them from libraries, but I link to Amazon because I know people will find the book there. I understand that Amazon is not a great company and they have been pushing booksellers out of the business (along with the lowering numbers of the reading public and the big box bookstores), but poetry can be difficult to find. I think even in independent bookstores, booksellers are guided by what sells and unfortunatley poetry is not a huge seller.

I have never tried Powell’s before, btw, but I did find this book online there. So here’s a link to the Powell’s reference for her book. http://www.powells.com/biblio/72-9781571314260-0

Sorry for the long response, but it is something that I have grappled with.

3. Reviews! Reviews! « 9 to 5 Poet - April 3, 2008

[...] Cups of Tea for the Uptown Neighborhood News and the second is my review of Deborah Keenan’s Willow Room, Green Door for read. write. poem.  Our PBC discussion on the latter will be posted next Monday.  [...]

4. Jessica - April 6, 2008

Hi everyone –

I interview Deborah via email this weekend, which I’ve posted on my blog here:

http://9to5poet.com/2008/04/07/interview-with-deborah-keenan/

Enjoy!

:)


welcome to read write poem

Read Write Poem is an online gathering place for those who love poetry — and for those who suspect that, with a little nurturing, they could grow to love poetry. Whether you are new to writing poetry or have been writing for years, you are welcome here. If you don’t write poetry but love to read and discuss it, this is also the place for you. Read more about the project.


Get the Read Write Poem badge for your site! We have two versions to choose from. Just click on the badge to the left to snag the code.


read write poll

Tell us about your interest in publishing your poetry in literary journals: (Select all that apply.)

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

other read write poem joints

Facebook (sign up to be added to our mailing list)
Twitter (sign up to be part of impromptu collaborative poem events and to learn more about what's going on with Read Write Poem)

participant-run journals, zines and sites


  • read write poem newsfeed

      Issue 3 of Ouroboros Review is live and includes the work of Dustin Brookshire, James Brush, Joyce Ellen Davis, Michelle McGrane and Carolee Sherwood!

      (Did we miss you? Tell us! Email news (at) readwritepoem (dot) org. Or send us your news!)

      -----

      Dustin Brookshire's Queens of Poetry anthology submission deadline is Sept. 30. Go here for more information.

      -----

      "W.S. Merwin join[ed] Bill Moyers for a wide-ranging conversation about language, his writing process, the natural world, and the insights gleaned from a much-lauded career of more than 50 years."

      He also read a great many of the poems from this year's Pulitzer prize-winning The Shadow of Sirius, published by Copper Canyon Press.

      This excellent program aired on June 26 and is well-worth the watch. Find it here, on PBS.

      -----

      Dave Bonta wants to know: "Why do poets say 'O'?"

      -----

      You can find a video of John Walsh reading "Gash" for Ouroboros Review here and look for a new issue very soon!

      Ouroboros Review is a biannual poetry and art magazine that will include three John Walsh poems in the upcoming issue.

      -----

  • random
    poetry prompt

      A different word or phrase will appear here each time you visit the site or refresh the page. Your current prompt is — descry

  • random
    collaborating tip

    Read a poem with a friend, and each of you compare notes about what you got from the poem.


  • random
    writing tip

    Write a narrative poem or an epic poem about an event in history that moves you. Do you feel drawn to a certain time period from the past? What about the music? It might be big band music, sixties folk rock, Duke Ellington jazz, Renaissance madrigals, Gregorian chants, sitar music, etc. Think of the food, the clothing, the setting and create a mood that’s evocative of the time period you’ve chosen.

  • random
    reading tip

    Do you know a poet whose work you admire? Ask them who they love to read or would recommend.

  • random
    poetry quote

    Everyday should begin with a poem. — Michelle McGrane