poetry book club: a review of matthea harvey’s modern life

I never thought I’d read a book of poetry about robots, let alone fall in love with it.

In Matthea Harvey’s Modern Life, technology, terror and emotional disconnection form an eerie patchwork of existence in our time. Harvey uses slightly surreal imagery and a unique vocabulary to construct her haunting vision. While Harvey’s voice can at first seem overtly intellectual, her fierce images build to create an intense reading experience.

I’ve tried to read Matthea Harvey before, with an earlier book - Pity the Bathtub Its Forced Embrace of the Human Form, and felt entirely left out. Her language seemed too cold, too removed and I didn’t “get” it. Maybe it was just me. (It’s happened before.) But I suggested Modern Life for January’s Poetry Book Club (PBC), having heard so many good things about it. When I started Modern Life I thought, “Here we go again.” Her images are strange and range from ham flowers to slaughtered sailors, with a menagerie of zoo animals stuck in between. And these examples are from only the first 3 or 4 poems.

For me the book improved in the second section, with her series “The Future of Terror.” These poems use a loose abecedarian form to explore the intense disconnectedness we feel following 9/11. In an endnote, Harvey describes her process in writing these. She began by making lists of words found in the dictionary between “future” and “terror.” While this could have created a haphazard list, Harvey instead constructs gems like “there is an intimacy to invasion” (2007, p. 11) and “We’d killed all the inventors and all / the jesters just when we most needed humor / and invention.” (2007, p. 22). Random? Yes, and true to our times.

One of the final sections contains poems entitled “The Terror of Future,” which leads us backwards alphabetically from terror to the future. With these two linguistic constructions framing her book, I am forced to question whether terror will lead us to the future or the future will lead us to terror. (Unfortunately, I believe both may be the case.)

The heart of Modern Life lies within the central section of prose poems, featuring Robo Boy. Robo Boy is a facsimile of a child, purchased by his parents, who is trying to understand what it means to be human. He certainly looks lifelike, with spray-on skin and eerie illuminated eyes, but he feels mechanized and empty.

My favorite Robo Boy poem is “Moving Day,” in which he tries to teach himself complex emotions. He is programmed for five base emotions, “HAPPY, SAD, ANGRY, CONFUSED and CONTENT” (2007, p. 45), but he knows the key to humanity holds more. So he crafts decorated semi-opaque sheets through which he can view the world.

For MELANCHOLY TINGED WITH SWEETNESS, he soaks the sheet in gloppy gray paint, pastes on ripped photographs of factories, and sprays the mess with Chanel No. 5. For TEARS TURNING TO LAUGHTER he sprinkles the top half with glitter and paints a baseline of blue. Tomorrow he will go on a walk with the sheets stored in his backpack. He’ll sit on a fence and look at the clouds, through exhilaration, hysteria, delight, despair. (2007, p. 45)

How different is Robo Boy’s experience than a typical child’s emotional education? Rather than using decorated Styrofoam sheets, children are left to view the world through media’s images (ripped photographs of factories) to develop their feelings.

I would highly recommend Matthea Harvey’s Modern Life. This is not a book that will make you feel optimistic about our present or our future. Instead, you will feel, like many of the central images in her book, cleaved in half by the omnipresent uncertainty and distant violence in our lives. Perhaps, as Harvey suggests in the final poem, “Setting the Table,” we are supposed to survive on the border between light and dark, day and night, safety and insecurity, in order to feel “just right” (2007, p. 82).

To learn more about Matthea Harvey and Modern Life, read interviews with her at Bookslut and Tarpaulin Sky. Of course, you are also invited to join – or listen in on – the Poetry Book Club discussion. Happy reading!

* * *

Harvey, Matthea. (2007). Modern Life: Poems. St. Paul: Graywolf Press.
Harvey, Matthea. (2000). Pity the Bathtub Its Forced Embrace of the Human Form. Farmington: Alice James Books.

Matthea Harvey’s website can be found at www.mattheaharvey.info .

* * *

February’s PBC book at 9 to 5 Poet is Leilani Hall’s Swimming the Witch. Discussions usually start the end of the month.

Hall, Leilani. (2005). Swimming the Witch. Cincinnati: Cherry Grove Collections-Wordtech Communications.

1. Christine - February 8, 2008

Jessica,
Your interpretaion of Robo-boy is spot on. As a reader, I felt as you did about her interpretation of the modern society. Reading her poems, I felt like i had entered a sort of Eward Scissorhands twighlight world. As a writer, I saw a whole imaginary world open up for myself. Matthea Harvey’s mind is so flexible. She makes the most clever and vivid connections, which influenced me to open up more in my own writing.

2. Jeannine Hall Gailey - February 13, 2008

Dear Jessica,
Good discussion! I really got a thrill from this book as well. In fact, there might be some info on my blog soon about an interview with Matthea somewhere cool…so keep checking :)


welcome to read write poem

Read Write Poem is an online gathering place for those who love poetry — and for those who suspect that, with a little nurturing, they could grow to love poetry. Whether you are new to writing poetry or have been writing for years, you are welcome here. If you don’t write poetry but love to read and discuss it, this is also the place for you. Read more about the project.


Get the Read Write Poem badge for your site! We have two versions to choose from. Just click on the badge to the left to snag the code.


read write poll

Tell us about your interest in publishing your poetry in literary journals: (Select all that apply.)

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

other read write poem joints

Facebook (sign up to be added to our mailing list)
Twitter (sign up to be part of impromptu collaborative poem events and to learn more about what's going on with Read Write Poem)

participant-run journals, zines and sites


  • read write poem newsfeed

      Issue 3 of Ouroboros Review is live and includes the work of Dustin Brookshire, James Brush, Joyce Ellen Davis, Michelle McGrane and Carolee Sherwood!

      (Did we miss you? Tell us! Email news (at) readwritepoem (dot) org. Or send us your news!)

      -----

      Dustin Brookshire's Queens of Poetry anthology submission deadline is Sept. 30. Go here for more information.

      -----

      "W.S. Merwin join[ed] Bill Moyers for a wide-ranging conversation about language, his writing process, the natural world, and the insights gleaned from a much-lauded career of more than 50 years."

      He also read a great many of the poems from this year's Pulitzer prize-winning The Shadow of Sirius, published by Copper Canyon Press.

      This excellent program aired on June 26 and is well-worth the watch. Find it here, on PBS.

      -----

      Dave Bonta wants to know: "Why do poets say 'O'?"

      -----

      You can find a video of John Walsh reading "Gash" for Ouroboros Review here and look for a new issue very soon!

      Ouroboros Review is a biannual poetry and art magazine that will include three John Walsh poems in the upcoming issue.

      -----

  • random
    poetry prompt

      A different word or phrase will appear here each time you visit the site or refresh the page. Your current prompt is — pleat

  • random
    collaborating tip

    Send a chainpoem to a collaborator through email or regular mail. Supply the first line and ask the recipient to supply another line then pass the poem on to someone else, and so on and so on, until a recipient adds a final line and deems the piece finished.


  • random
    writing tip

    Stay grounded in detail. When you write, allow as much detail as possible into your poem. You can always cut back later. Try to build a poem in which the details do all the work.

  • random
    reading tip

    Pick up a book of poems you don't think you would be drawn to. This may seem like a silly (and not very pleasant) thing to do, but the writing could surprise you. If you really don't like it, try to determine and articulate why. In the end, you will be a stronger writer (and reader!) by knowing what you don't like and your reasons for not liking it.

  • random
    poetry quote

    Poetry is what you find / in the dirt in the corner, -- Elizabeth Alexander